Tag Archives: Benjamin DeCasseres

Critic Sues Critic

In 1926, Benjamin DeCasseres collected the poems of his younger brother Walter and wrote the introduction to The Sublime Boy. According to the following newspaper item, James Oppenheim reviewed the book in the New York Evening Post and claimed that Walter had never existed. The Columbus Dispatch reported that a million-dollar libel suit followed.


Critic Sues Critic

Because the reviewer of a book said that its author never lived, the New York courts will have to decide on the merits of a $1,000,000 libel suit. The reviewer is James Oppenheim, poet, who, in reviewing “The Sublime Boy,” a collection of poems by Walter DeCasseres, in the New York Evening Post, declared that Walter DeCasseres never existed, and that Walter is a figment of the imagination of Benjamin DeCasseres, noted critic, who is attempting to hoax the American public.

In making announcement of the filing of the $1,000,000 libel suit, Ribman & Ribman, of New York city, attorneys for the plaintiffs, declared that this was one of the rare incidents in American literary history where one reviewer had occasion to sue another, as Benjamin DeCasseres and James Oppenheim had both been reviewing books for the New York Evening Post.


“Critic Sues Critic,” The Columbus Dispatch (Columbus, Ohio), January 2, 1927, p. 84.

Find Authors’ Tastes Differ

In 1932, the United Press asked American writers and editors to name three recently published books they particularly liked. Benjamin DeCasseres chose Stefan Zweig’s Mental Healers, Oswald Spengler’s The Decline of the West, and Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World. His selections appeared alongside those of H. L. Mencken, Fannie Hurst, and other contributors.


Find Authors’ Tastes Differ

NEW YORK (U.P.)—Literary tastes differ among leading authors and editors of the United States, according to a symposium collected by the United Press.

A number of prominent writers were asked to name three recently published books particularly to their liking. Their selections follow:

H. L. Mencken, editor The American Mercury: The Messiah Jesus and John the Baptist, by Robert Eisler; The Mysterious Madame, by C. E. Bechofer Roberts; The Work, Wealth, and Happiness of Mankind, by H. G. Wells.

Carl Van Doren, editor The Literary Guild: Expression in America, by Ludwig Lewisohn; Wellington, by Philip Guedalla; The Social Life of Apes and Monkeys, by S. Zuckerman.

Fannie Hurst

Fannie Hurst, novelist: The Good Earth, by Pearl S. Buck; Russia, by Hans von Eckhardt.

Christpher Morley, novelist and critic: The Tragedy of Henry Ford, by Jonathan Leonard; Kamonga, by Homer W. Smith; And Life Goes On, by Vici Baum.

Alexander Woolcott, critic: Stepping Westward, by Laura E. Richards; The Unseen Assassins, by Norman Angell; Loads of Love, by Anne Parrish.

Benjamin DeCasseres, critic: Mental Healers, by Stefan Zweig; The Decline of the West, by Oswald Spengler; Brave New World, by Aldous Huxley.

Anthony Abbott

Anthony Abbott, detective novel writer: Death Answers the Bell, by Valentine Williams; The Kennel Murder Case, by S. S. Van Dine; The Documents in the Case, by Dorothy Sayres.

William McFee, novelist—Way of the Lancer, by Richard Boleslavsky; Rackety Rax, by Joel Sayre; Seventy Years in Archaeology, by Sir Flinders Petrie.

George Jean Nathan, critic: Essays in Persuasion, by L. M. Keynes; The Story of My Life, by Clarence Darrow; “The Puritan, by Liam O’Flaherty.

Ben Hecht, novelist: “It’s nobody’s business what I read.”

Gene Fowler, novelist: Dr. Hofstetter’s Spavin & Gold Cure Almanac; Pueblo, Colo., telephone directory, issue of 1902; Black Beauty.

Harry Elmer Barnes, author and critic: Only Yesterday, by Frederick Lewis Allen; The Story of My Life, by Clarence Darrow; Is Capitalism Doomed? by Dennis.


United Press, “Find Authors’ Tastes Differ,” Progress-Bulletin (Pomona, California), May 12, 1932, p. 14.

America’s Most Unpublished Author

As published in the San Bernardino Sun, Volume 67, Number 23, 23 September 1930


Intelligentsia Pole Star Gives Bernard Shaw Merciless Flaying In Volume Lauding H.L Mencken

America’s Most Unpublished Author at Last ‘Clicks’ and Works to Be Printed

By H. ALLEN SMITH (United Press Correspondent) NEW YORK, Sept. 22.

Benjamin Decasseres, pole star of the American intelligentsia and sometimes called the most unpublished author in the United States, has written a new book that will be published. It is called “Mencken and Shaw, the Anatomy of America’s Voltaire and England’s Other John Bull.” Between its covers Decasseres sets out, with a pen that drips blue fire, to prove that George Bernard Shaw is a colossal mountebank and that H. L. Mencken is the true modern Voltaire.

Lives in Apartment Off Gramercy Park

This being an interesting thesis, Decasseres submitted to an interview. He lives in an apartment off Gramercy park surrounded by books, green pencils, unpublished manuscripts and an ice box well stocked with tannic acid. The “Lone Eagle” of American literature wore brown striped pajamas, of a silken texture, during the interview. First off he brought out his 16 unpublished books. These range in topic from a volume of poetry to the love letters of Bio and Benjamin Decasseres. “The publishers,” Decasseres said, “won’t touch my stuff because I won’t go to literary teas.” His new volume on Mencken and Shaw will be published by Silas Newton, a Texas oil man. Newton may publish all of Decasseres works. The 57-year-old author believes that Mencken’s books should be placed in the schools, “to teach Americans how to write English.” He holds that Mencken is the greatest writer as well as the greatest social satirist this country has ever produced. “I have taken Mencken and Shaw,” he said, “as the world’s two outstanding sane rebels. But my idea is that Mencken’s sanity is sincere, while Shaw’s is not. Shaw delights in making people believe he is insane, which he probably is. He is a cheap publicity-seeker, a publicity-shark of the lowest type. He is like a trick bear, always clowning. “The big difference lies in the fact that Mencken has character, Shaw has none. I don’t agree with Mencken on many of his literary and esthetic judgments. But I believe that his grandeur comes from his narrowness, his height comes from his lack of breadth. “Mencken glories in the use of words. He takes the same pleasure in studying the use of words that a Beethoven would take in the study of notes, or a Rembrandt in the study of colors.” The frequent charge of insincerity, brought against Mencken, irritates Decasseres.

Has Been Pursuing One Line of Thought

“For 20 years.” he said, “the man has been following one solid line of thought a battering ram against sham and humbug and popular idols. My objection to him is that he is monotonously sincere. I wish he would change his record occasionally.” Decasseres said that Shaw has never created a character that will live, that he is the “father of all the sophisticated drool that exists on the stage today. He is the greatest disaster to the English stage of the century. He cannot create human beings, only epigrani-spouters, and he creates his characters to fit his epigrams instead of letting the epigrams flow naturally from the characters. I might add that he gats all his epigrams from jazzing up Schopenhauer, Neitzsche, Tolstoy, La Rochefocauld, Oscar Wilde and Samuel Butler. Shaw is related to the world of great artist? as jazz composers are related to Beethoven and Mozart.” Decasseres sent the proofs of his book to Mencken, who in- turn wrote a letter to the author. The last line of this letter reads: “You forgot to put in that I was baptized at the age of two months and had the hives for five weeks thereafter.”