Category Archives: Essays/Articles

Rasputin and the Empress

As seen by Benjamin DeCasseres

The Barrymore family will, in a hundred years, be a legend, or an historical fact both glamorous and romantic. They are the Medici Family of the stage—Catherine-Ethel Medici-Barrymore, Lorenzo the Magnificent, alias John Barrymore, and Allesandro Lionel Medici-Barrymore.

Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer had the grand idea of putting the three Barrymores into a play. They chose a subject that fits the three Barrymores like a slug of whisky fits the gullet of a drink-snooper. The story is “Rasputin and the Empress,” done by Charles MacArthur and splendidly directed and sumptuously conceived by Richard Boleslavsky. At its world-premiere at the New York Astor it was followed absorbingly by as brilliant and as famous an audience as I have seen at an opening in many years.

I can see nothing for “Rasputin and the Empress” but a hundred per cent box office attraction. Besides the tremendous pulling power of the names Lionel, Ethel and John (they could drop their last names entirely and still everybody would know who you are talking about), the scenarist and the director have put into this terrific (but sometimes slow-moving) drama of the fall of a mighty empire every ingredient that attracts and holds all classes of picture fans: romance, suspense, murder, battle, war-tensity, bitter humor, palatial sets, gaudy costuming and vivid characterizations.

The story of the strange monk who cured the Czar’s son by hypnotism when all medical aid had failed, his life-and-death grip on the Romanoffs, his decline, his murder and the catastrophe of 1914 follows very closely the historical facts. There has been injected into the story—and very plausibly—a Prince Chegodieff and his sweetheart, Princess Natasha. It is because Rasputin, feeling his power invincible, has assaulted Natasha that Prince Chegodieff falls upon this diabolical monk and in a terrific scene—one of the most effective ever seen on the screen—pounds Rasputin almost to death with an iron bar and throws his body into the Neva.

As for the story, the only criticism I can make is that it should be tightened up in the first few reels. There are scenes where I felt the audience fidget.

The acting of the Barrymores was, in the main, superb, with the palm going to John Barrymore as the romantic Prince Chegodieff. I have always affirmed that John was the greatest of the Barrymores—when he wanted to be. Lately he has played a lot of monkeyshines. He seems, sometimes, to be spoofing himself, the role and the public. But in this picture he gives us the very best that is in him. Here are artistic sincerity, simplicity and directness, with the irritating mannerisms entirely deleted.

Ethel Barrymore looked superb and acted with dignity (every inch a queen) as the Czarina. She is at her best when she is awakened to the real character of Rasputin after the attack on Princess Natasha. A little less eye-rolling, however, would have aided her.

Lionel Barrymore as Rasputin was powerful and compelling—in spots. He has, of course, got to wear whiskers, and that always is a cause of laughter (mental, at least). When he tries to be diabolical he is least effective and more effective when he suggests evil than when he dishes it out.

“Rasputin and the Empress” will, I believe, be shown eventually in every picture-house in the country. It is a major event, both from an artistic and a box office point of view.

Produced and distributed by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. Directed by Richard Boleslavsky. Author, Charles MacArthur. Musical score by Herbert Stothart. Photography by William Daniels. Film editor, Tom Held. Running time, 127 minutes.

CAST

Prince Chegodieff — John Barrymore

The Czarina — Ethel Barrymore

Rasputin — Lionel Barrymore

The Czar — Ralph Morgan

Princess Natasha — Diana Wynyard

The Czarevitch — Tad Alexander

Grand Duke Igor — C. Henry Gordon

Doctor Remezov — Edward Arnold

Original publication
Benjamin DeCasseres, “Rasputin and the Empress,” Motion Picture Herald, December 31, 1932, p. 36.

Life a Babel to Hall Caine

Letter to the editor

To The New York Times’s Saturday Review:

I quite agree with your correspondent of several weeks since in her estimate of the artistic worth of Mr. Hall Caine’s “The Christian”—particularly as revealed in its dramatization at one of the New York theatres. Art’s highest mission, as I conceive it, is to faithfully reproduce life, and he is the greatest artist who, conformably to those other elements which enter into the production of a masterpiece, most thoroughly eliminates the personal equation and presents the particular under universal aspects; or, as an eminent contemporary critic has it, he who gives the widest possible generalizations to his personal experiences. Judged by this standard, “The Christian” must certainly be classed as an egregious failure. Mr. Caine does not view the world as it is; he does not see civilization as a unit. To him life is a babel of confusing voices, where there are no laws, no coherency, no logical sequences. London is the world, and the world is going to Mantalini’s “demnition bow-wows.”

He is everywhere absolute in his judgments. Everything in life, he holds, is broadly labeled. A thing is either good or bad, and when it is good, it is very, very good, and when it is bad, it could not be worse. The self-seeking materialism and sensualism of the age are to be horsewhipped into spiritual subjection by a wild-eyed fanaticism—John Storm, high priest; Glory Quayle, high priestess.

His type of people is exceptional—Horatio Drake excepted. Nothing proceeds logically and according to well-ascertained mental laws. His central character—Glory Quayle—is a psychological impossibility. She inhales an atmosphere that could hardly be worse; she willingly chooses to be the associate of card sharpers, “faro” kings, seducers of women, and “actresses” whose ways are dark and whose rouge is vain. How long can a woman remain pure in an atmosphere contaminated by the constant presence of Lord Robert Ure, Betty Bellman, and the “Faro King”? And, forsooth, according to Mr. Caine, Glory remains not only spotlessly immaculate, but he implies that she does not know the simplest facts of life. She accepts the patronage and presents of Horatio Drake and never dreams—— She deserts this life of a sudden to seek refuge with a man who is a mediæval fanatic, thinly veneered with modern socialistic sophisms; a man who would not only “save” the world by a forcible imposition of his ideas on a backward generation, but who would gain the object of his love à la Sutton Vane and Frank Harvey. Hysteria! hysteria! and nothing else. When the world shall need regeneration it will find it in Faith plus Will, not in Mr. Caine’s ill-smelling nostrum of Fanaticism plus Hysteria.

Lord Robert Ure’s original has probably never been seen outside the classic Adelphi. He is an unspeakably vulgar creation, and bears as great a likeness to genuine flesh-and-blood villainy as the art of Caine bears to that of Shakespeare, the former’s massive sinciput to the contrary notwithstanding. Villainy in this life does not go around placarded as such—and Ure’s villainy is written in circus-poster type from the top of his head to the bottom of his boots.

The one true-to-life character in the play is Horatio Drake. He leaves us mystified; we do not quite fathom his motives; he is elusive. And is it not so in this life? Do we show our hearts to each other in their nakedness? Can we always fathom our own motives for action, much less those of our fellow-beings? And is there not an elusiveness about those who surround us, no matter how closely we are associated with them? They are mysteries to us ever, and no man may be judged with infallible certainty. Mr. Caine dimly perceived this in creating Drake. He is Mr. Caine’s one artistic conception, so far as “The Christian” is concerned, if the minor Mrs. Callender be excepted. In Drake the mirror is held up to nature.

“The Christian,” as a whole, is a good melodrama, but with a melodrama’s limitations. I believe the next generation of critics will suspend Mr. Caine, like Mohammed’s coffin, in that thin ethereal region midway between the heaven of romanticism and the terra firma of realism—the cynosure of curious eyes.

BENJAMIN DE CASSERES.

Philadelphia, March 31, 1899.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Life a Babel to Hall Caine,” New York Times Saturday Review, April 15, 1899, pp. 243–244 (page numbers from the bibliography).

Letter on Henri Frédéric Amiel

Letter to the editor

The New York Times Saturday Review of Books:

IN answering a correspondent in last week’s issue of THE REVIEW you say that some admirers of Henri Frédéric Amiel have called him the “Thoreau of Switzerland.” No more absurd comparison, in my opinion, is conceivable than one between Amiel and Thoreau. The latter was riantly optimistic, at bottom a dogmatist, a man to whom—like Emerson—evil scarcely existed. Amiel, on the other hand, was the saddest skeptic the European world has known. He bit the apple that fell to him from the Tree of Knowledge, Good, and Evil, and found a worm at the core. Thoreau ate his apple and knocked off another with a club.

The philosopher of Geneva was the lordliest victim that that great Moloch, the Ideal, ever claimed. His was a regal soul felled by Thought. He had a brain that was as subtle as light, an interior eye that pierced all the veils of Maya, the god of illusion. He lived a solitary god of futile dreams. Thoreau’s life could hardly be called “futile.”

There is no book in the world like the “Journal Intime.” It is the recorded minutiæ of a soul in hell. Montaigne, St. Augustine, Rousseau, Maurice de Guérin pale their fires before this feat of introspective surgery. The great self-revealers—if Montaigne be excepted—are surface minds compared to this awful revelation of a Hamlet who walked the ramparts of his ghost-ridden Elsinore for fifty years. The “Journal Intime” is the confession of a modern Prometheus chained to the granite wall of Necessity, his vitals picked by the vultures of Doubt.

Amiel was a Hindu Yogi, who had once reached Nirvana, but who had again fallen into flesh. He was like a spectator who stood on the bank of the River of Time and watched the hurried flow of all the baubles of earth over the troubled surface. He was petrified by a vision of the Infinite. Half his soul lay mobile in eternity; the other half trailed through the sewers of matter.

He saw all sides of all problems. He knew that an opinion on any subject excluded an opposite opinion. Hegel had said that all opinion was guilt. Amiel wrote a book to prove it. To Amiel to live was a kind of sin. And it was not the sour pessimism of worldly failure that uttered this, but it was wisdom’s last word, the calm conclusion of one of the intellectual giants of the age. And in this was he not at one with the Hindu philosophers, with Sophocles, the author of Ecclesiastes, Aeschylus, Buddha, Lucretius, Plato, Hegel, Schopenhauer, Leopardi, Thomas Hardy? Like Pascal, Amiel suffered all things, groped through all the varying phases of his mind—to find no exit. Pain alone was real to him; all else was illusion. He could not jest like Renan or Anatole France, nor mock like Flaubert, nor hate like Nietzsche. He was too religious—that is, he doubted too much—to find the solaces of these other men. He picked all things to pieces and strewed the wreckage over the literary world, tossing his own heart and brain and bone into the débris. But he wept as he destroyed; he lashed himself anew at each denial. His infidelity was a prayer. His denials were flagellations.

Born in a scientific, a utilitarian era, Amiel saw about him thousands of men setting forth on voyages of discovery. But he knew there was nothing to discover. There are only change, illusion, endless motion. His great, sad soul was a hermit in an alien universe—a hermit tortured by dreams of the Infinite, a hermit who finally committed spiritual hari-kari.

BENJAMIN DE CASSERES.

New York, July 25.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Letter on Henri Frédéric Amiel,” New York Times Saturday Review, July 31, 1909, p. 469 (page number from the bibliography).

Hawthorne and the Intangible Life

Letter to the editor

New York Times Saturday Review of Books:

THE NEW YORK TIMES SATURDAY REVIEW OF BOOKS to-day answers splendidly and completely the superficial criticisms of Mr. Brownell on the art of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Mr. Brownell seems to be utterly unfitted to comprehend the “meditative mind.”

Hawthorne, like Amiel and Maurice de Guérin and Maurice Maeterlinck, is a type of being to whom the Intangible Life is an existence within an existence. We have been told about the Simple Life and the Strenuous Life, but who has time for the Intangible Life?

To beings such as Hawthorne the nearest thing is the remotest thing, the remotest thing is the nearest thing. They can put their hands on Arcturus and Aldebaran familiarly, but their bedroom bureaus they do not know. They are never quite socketed in their environment, never quite come into contact with their own bodies; the world is a myth of their brains, something conjured up by the wand of a Prospero; a haunted house at most—and this it seemed to Hawthorne. Their lives—such as Hawthorne’s—are meditations.

Hawthorne, read through his works, always seemed to be a man who was resolving a problem, and the flag of his spirit was always at half-mast for the obscure griefs that sucked away at his heart. The world to him was a ghost-walk, the green earth spinning around the sun only a troubled Elsinore. In that mystic imagination of his, which Mr. Brownell looks at with implied contempt, there were the fragmentary records of pasts long swallowed up; the shining dust of worlds crumbled beyond all possibility of reintegration, whirling black meteoric stones flung from the wreck of his own incalculable past selves—and the sorrow of all of this was set in his eyes. Those eyes! They seemed to be the lighted memory of some golden minute overlooked by Oblivion, a miraculous survival in his consciousness of a wondertime, a magical reminiscence that spoiled for him all this sickly fret called “contemporaneous life.”

Certain beings there are—of which Hawthorne and Poe were types—who seeem to be doing a work in some other sphere, to be occupied elsewhere, to be forced guests of earth, looking on things about them as clumsy forgeries of a thing done otherwhere on finer parchment than stone and wave and flesh and blood. Hawthorne was smitten with the Infinite, he was of the centaurs. Their brooding, wistful faces peer across the sills of the House of Revels and they pass on, unallied, aliens beneath an alien sun. They pity Time itself—Time, which seems to them overweighted, forever and forever holding up this accumulating burden of evil, this daily increment of inutile dream and deed, this perpetual postponement of final ends, with its stupidity of being “on the job.”

BENJAMIN DE CASSERES.

New York, Dec. 30.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Hawthorne and the Intangible Life,” New York Times Saturday Review, January 4, 1908, p. 8 (page number from the bibliography).

Children of the Ghetto

Letter to the editor

A letter appeared in last week’s issue of THE REVIEW, headed “Children of the Ghetto,” from Irene Carter, who asks: “Is there any feeling but honor in our hearts for the old man, (Reb Shemuel,) who by his decision obeyed his law, his God, even though it tore out his own and even his daughter’s heart?” There is certainly in my heart another feeling than honor. Any man that opposes, in the name of religion, an abstract, utterly irrational, pre-Christian law to the pure, holy, human, and sane instincts of a woman’s heart is a fanatic. Torquemada had what he called his “idea of duty”—it was to forcibly save souls from hell by bodily torture. Reb Shemuel is a modern survivor of this inquisitor. He tortures spiritually because the rack is proscribed. Religion! That is the sublimest religion of all that teaches eternal constancy in love. Reb Shemuel is a man who believes in the letter, and the letter killeth, while the spirit saveth. I should have felt like shouting for joy had the lovers in “The Children of the Ghetto” thrown the glove of revolt in Reb’s face, rushed into each other’s arms, and thence shaken the dust of the Ghetto forever from their heels, and lived their lives according to the dictates of their hearts. Honor indeed! Honor to those who do their duty; and to do one’s duty is simply to do what is right; and to do what is right is to live according to the highest in you—not the highest in somebody else who lived 2,000 years ago.

BENJ. DE CASSERES.

New York, Nov. 20, 1899.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Children of the Ghetto,” New York Times Saturday Review, December 9, 1899, p. 863 (page number from the bibliography).

Not Fiction, but Great Truths

Letter to the editor

To The New York Times Saturday Review:

Some of your correspondents who “take me up” in your issue of last week for my letter decrying the excessive novel reading of the day are apparently laboring under the impression that I am opposed to the novel per se. Nothing is further from the truth. No one places the art of the novel writer higher than I do, and I hold that when one has read “The Scarlet Letter,” “Vanity Fair,” “L’Assommoir,” “Richard Feveral,” and “Henry Esmond,” he has read five of the literary masterpieces of the age. To me they are not fiction, but great truths, to be absorbed into the woof and weft of one’s spiritual nature. I do not indict the novel, but the novel-reading public—those who in our libraries allow Goethe, Taine, Spencer, and Browning to grow cobwebbed with persistent disuse, and who crowd around the frothy fiction cases like flies around the sugarbowl. The majority of these latter read merely for amusement—seldom for instruction. They belong to that class of people who subscribe to The Daily Batteringram and Evening Shock, and who patronize the Girl from Paris and the latest disrobing humbug from oversea.

They live by and through their feelings. Their higher centres have become atrophied through a long period of poisonous desuetude. To them Darwin is the man who said, “We come from monkeys,” Henry George “That man who believes in killing the rich,” and Browning—“Why, ain’t he the poet who had a fight with his father-in-law?” They know next to nothing of the tremendous philosophic, religious, economic movements of the age, which are intimately connected with the fortunes of you and me and all of us. As Prof. James says, these people are becoming a source of danger to the National character. Novels are sapping their strength; they welter in emotions and revel in the warm baths of sense—though they would indignantly disclaim any such thing. One correspondent tells me that there is enough of the tragic in life without reading Ibsen. Parodoxical as it may seem, I reply that there is so much tragedy in life because we don’t make our lives tragical enough. No ill was ever gotten over by ignoring it. Ibsen has grappled with the problems of all time. All hail to the grapplers and fighters! The kingdom of the spirit does not belong to moon-struck Le Gallienne or broadsword Kipling, but to the Ibsens and Zolas, Tolstoïs, Turgeneffs, and Hauptmanns.

We have had enough of the novel for awhile. The new century is portentous with ominous signs. Rose Nouchette Carey, Mrs. Alexander, Hall Caine, and Le Gallienne are doing nothing to interpret them. They hold a preponderating influence in the world of literature to-day—even among the cultivated; but, as Goethe says, “among those we call cultivated there is little earnestness to be found.” And let us hope that the first shall be last.

BENJAMIN DE CASSERES.

Philadelphia, Penn., Oct. 24, 1899.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Not Fiction, but Great Truths,” New York Times Saturday Review, November 11, 1899, p. 764 (page number from the bibliography).

Too Much Fiction

Letter to the editor

To The New York Times Saturday Review:

I want to register a protest. I read THE SATURDAY REVIEW every week and immensely enjoy the fare spread before me. I read all the letters that are sent to you, Mr. Editor—that is, those that you make public—and yet I am tired. In the name of heaven, does anybody in this broad land read books on sociology, psychology, morphology, pedagogy, art, science, religion, politics, philosophy? Will the wisdom of all the world die with novelists? I am satiated, saturated, inundated, interpenetrated with Henry James, Robert Louis Stevenson, Hardy, Cable, Robins, Howells, Swift, Weyman, Caine, Zangwill, and a host of others “too numerous to mention.”

Are there any among your readers who read Spencer, Huxley, Le Bon, Tolstoi, Ibsen, Taine, Emerson, Swinburne, Watson, Bourget, (who is not a novelist,) Kelvin, Ribot, or Moll? Give us a rest on the novel for awhile, dear emotion seekers. Go up against the proper thing—as my friend Chuck Connors would say. Take a day off and read a few of the big guys. I warrant it to cure you all of that disputatious mania which wrangles over such a question as, “Do dates grow in Camden?” as Mrs. Bobbins asserts in her latest novel, or does Henry James understand the difference between foulard and mousseline de soie?

Having relieved my mind, I return to Brandes’s Ibsen and leave your correspondents to Laura Jean Libbey and Hall Caine.

BENJAMIN DE CASSERES.

Philadelphia.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Too Much Fiction,” New York Times Saturday Review, October 7, 1899, p. 674 (page number from the bibliography).

Thinks It a Powerful Psychological Novel

Letter to the editor

To The New York Times Saturday Review:

After reading the numerous letters which THE SATURDAY REVIEW has published in condemnation of “The Triumph of Death,” “The Open Question,” and other novels of the naturalistic school—which series, by the way, culminated in a particularly drastic communication last week—one is tempted to believe that there are some persons to whom has been vouchsafed a special revelation in a department of human thought that has been in a controversial state since the memory of man runneth not to the contrary. The cocksure manner in which certain books are relegated to the limbo of “bad art,” the perfect assurance with which “standards” to govern the production of a work of art are proclaimed, and the sublime egotism with which personal likes and dislikes are injected into these discussions cause one to smile. In my humble opinion, Mr. Editor, what we need most in art criticism is tolerance; less “taste” and more philosophy; less cant about “idealism,” “realism,” “naturalism,” and a little more genuine inquiry into the causes which produce such novels as “The Open Question,” “Jude the Obscure,” and “The Triumph of Death.” An artist does not produce what he wants to produce: he produces what he must. Has he delineated well? Has he brought out salient characteristics? Has he conveyed his meaning in convincing manner? That is what I look for in art.

For my part I think “The Triumph of Death” one of the most powerful psychological novels ever written. I think D’Annunzio a master. And they who say that this novel conveys no moral lesson must certainly be lacking in perceptive power. Yet my admiration for D’Annunzio’s book, great as it is, is no greater than is my admiration for “Cyrano de Bergerac.” I see beauty and truth in both. The former holds me firmly to earth, while the latter spiritually uplifts me, and both are necessary to keep me properly ballasted. To discover the laws which govern the things of sense is as important (nay, as ennobling) as to dream of that which we hope will be.

The battle between idealism and realism in philosophy and art is as old as human thought. I believe both have a portion of the truth. The world would be inconceivable without either; and there is nothing to be gained by the disciples of the ideal stigmatizing the realists in fiction as “neurotic” or the realists applying the epithet of “moonbeam idolaters” to the former.

BENJAMIN DE CASSERES.

Philadelphia, April 22, 1899.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Thinks It a Powerful Psychological Novel,” New York Times Saturday Review, May 13, 1899, p. 315 (page number from the bibliography).

Hon. Thomas B. Reed

It is an interesting fact, and one which has never been successfully gainsaid, that no country in the world furnishes in its political construction such a fair field as the United States for the meteor-like ascendency of comparatively unknown men in politics. The history of this government furnishes some striking examples of the foregoing fact—and also some “striking examples” of rising politicians who have prematurely—to them—been relegated to the “shades of private life.” Of all the men who have risen in this manner, there is not one who can successfully compare with the phenomenal success which the Hon. Thomas B. Reed, of Maine, has attained. It is not exaggerating in the least to say that no man in recent years has created such bitter and prejudiced enemies, or likewise drawn around him such a partisan and admiring following as he.

The Northern and Southern Democratic press, alike, have united in one bitter and unceasing tirade against him, and have well-nigh used up all their invective in the attempt to crush him; but, like Banquo’s ghost, he “will not down.” They have launched at him every epithet, from a “modern Cæsar” to an “insolent puppy,” ever since that memorable day in the history of the House of Representatives when he “dared” to count a man as being present who was present. His name has become famous from Maine to California, from Minnesota to Texas, as has no other man’s in so short a time.

By the sober-minded, sensible people of the country, and those who are more or less free from prejudiced partisanship, he is sincerely admired for his sterling patriotism and enormous amount of common-sense.

What has he done to cause this great commotion? What has he said or done to bring forth the “flowing oratory” of a Bland, a Breckenridge, a Springer, a Holman, and a Crisp? He has simply established a precedent which will be followed without the slightest twinge of conscience by Messrs. Bland, Holman, Crisp & Co. whenever their party shall gain control of the House. No one denies the latter fact with any show of sincerity, therefore it is really not a question of right or wrong with the Democratic party, but simply a question of power. He has rightly enunciated the sound doctrine, that when the people of the sovereign States of this country go to the ballot-box and there elect a Congress which shall represent the predominant thought of the country, especially if it is done on a straight-out issue, as was the case in the congressional elections of 1888, that Congress shall legislate according to the wishes of said majority, and if a turbulent minority do not acquiesce in the wish of the majority as elected by the people, and attempt to block all legislation by parliamentary and even unparliamentary tactics, it is right and reasonable to suppress such unpatriotic obstruction by laying down a code of rules which, of course, shall be within the bounds of constitutional law; and who makes the assertion that those adopted by the present House of Representatives are not? What Speaker of the House has had to contend against such virulent and bitter language as has assailed him on the floor of the House? What has been his conduct under these trying circumstances? Has he lowered himself and his honorable position by descending into the arena of vituperation which his enemies have built around him? No! he has acted like the high-minded and sensible man that he is, and stood as firm as a rock, unshaken and undaunted in the midst of the riotous tumult which characterized the proceedings of the present lower house of Congress; firm in the belief that he was right, and knowing that it was simply the rant of a partisan rabble, and that, when the smoke of battle would clear away, they who were loudest in their condemnation of his course would acknowledge he was right.

What has been the result of what the Democracy delight to term “Reedism” in the House, and how have his rules worked? Where is all the dire disaster that was predicted would accrue from the adoption of Reed’s methods? Where, oh! where is the test case that Mr. John G. Carlisle was engineering to carry to the Supreme Court? Under Mr. Carlisle’s rules in the House, last year, the tariff bill was not passed until July 21st; but were it not for the antiquated rules of the Senate and the allowance of such long-winded speeches as Messrs. Blair and Voorhees deliver on special occasions, the pending tariff bill would have been already signed by the president.

Besides the passage of a tariff bill, the House has passed a measure of equal if not greater importance than the McKinley bill: a measure which should be entitled “A Bill for the Suppression of Southern Bulldozing and Northern Corruption.” They have also passed a silver bill, a dependent pension bill, a bill for the admission of Idaho and Wyoming, and numerous bills of minor importance. Is not this a record to be proud of? If it be charged that they have mostly been passed through Reed’s able leadership, the Republican party pleads guilty.

The American people admire a man with backbone, and if there lives a man who possesses it, that man is the Hon. Thomas B. Reed, of Maine.

Benj. De Casseres.

Philadelphia, Pa.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “Hon. Thomas B. Reed,” Belford’s Magazine, vol. V, no. 29, October 1890, pp. 775–777.

6,000 Ways to Say It

By Benjamin De Casseres.

GIOVANNI PAPINI, the Italian iconoclastic and sometimes humorous, all too humorous, philosopher, has written an amusing sketch for one of the magazines called “The Satanic Genius.” It tells of the quest of a youthful worshipper of a world famous poet who lives in Paris. The poet’s Satanism has thrilled the world and made the gooseflesh vibrant where none had vibrated before.

The breathless disciple after many attempts at last stands face to face with the Master in the latter’s very commonplace apartment. And the Great Man is still more commonplace—a sort of baldheaded and bowlegged D’Annunzio.

To the killing astonishment of the believing boy the Genius relates just how he concocts his flights, aphorisms, demoniacal frenzies and super-vamps. Even shows him his catalogue of paradoxes, his dictionaries of obsolete phrases and words, his assortment of nude jokes, medical terms—in fact, all the trappings and Liberty Motors that beautify the outside and buzz inside of Pegasus!

He relates his money wrangles with his publishers and bows out the young man with a satanic grin after explaining that the water colors on the wall were painted by his wife.

This is the very triumph of Satanism, but the boy didn’t know it—and he probably hopped off the Pont Neuf forthwith.

In the age long controversy whether genius is a matter of infinite pains or inspiration, Signor Papini seems to go in for the infinite pains side. Inspiration, anyhow, is only the result of the infinite pains of our ancestors. All the words that Shakespeare used in his plays are in the dictionary. Take twenty thousand of them, sit down some Saturday afternoon and arrange them as Shakespeare knew the trick and—pouf!—you’ll have something bigger than Hamlet on your paper. Personally having been a genius up until my fortieth year, and having then given it up in order to live decently, I can now blazon the secret of the concoction of those great books that no publisher will publish—Roget’s Thesaurus, the Standard Dictionary, Walker’s Rhyming Dictionary, Smith’s Classical Dictionary, Woods’s Dictionary of Quotations and a briar root pipe, mixed with tea and rum.

But here comes another ready genius maker just as we were all going in for Bolshevism and root beer. It is A Dictionary of 6,000 Phrases, compiled and arranged by Edwin Hamlin Carr. It is an aid to ready and effective conversation and to social letter writing, with over 100 model social letters. It is (Papini, Pegasus and fooling aside) a valuable book for beginners in the art of conventionalizing their style if they flout the genius game. The author truly says “We think in phrases as well as words.” Can you deny it? And here is the phrase for any exigency, social, political, religious or literary.

A person that could memorize them all would go through the world as slickly as a kitten in a molasses factory. He would be a perfect genius of manners, poise, courtesy and grace, the Fourteen Points of elegance and the Ten Commandments of fashion. May I venture to suggest that with this book one could write a peace treaty that posterity would look on as a Magna Charta of Thought?

At the top of each page there is an index word. Suppose, for instance, you are interested in “Progress.” Page 203 is your cubbyhole. Here are “the chariot of progress,” “an aggressive movement,” “a thorough going reform,” &c. In fact there are 17,000 ready made editorials right on this page. Every man his own brisbane.

As I am seriously thinking of becoming a genius again, thanks, Mr. Editor, for this valuable book.

A Dictionary of 6,000 Phrases. Compiled by Edwin Hamlin Carr. G. P. Putnam’s Sons.

Original publication
Benjamin De Casseres, “6,000 Ways to Say It,” The Sun (New York), July 20, 1919, p. 8.